Meanwhile in Alberta......?

[mustardman]

So let’s see if I have this straight. We had the lowest Corporate tax in the country, but we gave up $4.7 billion in taxes by reducing that by 33%. We scrapped the carbon tax which put $2 billion into revenue, now we pay federal carbon tax. We also cancelled rail contracts which would have put another $2 billion into revenue. And we refuse to impose a 5% sales tax which would add another $5 billion to our revenue. My question is this - “How much gall does it take the only Province in the Country without a sales tax, to go to Ottawa and claim to deserve a $2.4 billion handout?

[jazz]

“How much gall does it take the only Province in the Country without a sales tax, to go to Ottawa and claim to deserve a $2.4 billion handout?

Hmmm, let me think, about as much as a province that massages its revenues to be have not then takes hundreds of billions of transfers from AB.

[Guest]

Hmmm, let me think, about as much as a province that massages its revenues to be have not then takes hundreds of billions of transfers from AB.

and collecting welfare every fu-cking year since inception?

[15444]

You seem to be salivating over tax money like a regular old hammer n sickle fanatic.

Separation is the only way for all of Alberta's money to stay in Alberta. People seem slow to take that in. I mean really slow.

Everytime Kenney is with Ottawa, he might as well stick an apple in his mouth, get on all fours and squeal like a pig because Trudeau is not going to give one shit about the West - Liberals don't need it to win.

Now go grab yourself an apple.

[Oliver88]

Typical socialist believes everyone’s income belongs to the government. Why did mustardman forget to mention the real reason Alberta is unhappy?

[Hamloc]

So let’s see if I have this straight. We had the lowest Corporate tax in the country, but we gave up $4.7 billion in taxes by reducing that by 33%. We scrapped the carbon tax which put $2 billion into revenue, now we pay federal carbon tax. We also cancelled rail contracts which would have put another $2 billion into revenue. And we refuse to impose a 5% sales tax which would add another $5 billion to our revenue. My question is this - “How much gall does it take the only Province in the Country without a sales tax, to go to Ottawa and claim to deserve a $2.4 billion handout?

At 12% we didn't have the lowest corporate tax rate in Canada, Quebec is 11.6% and Ontario 11.5%. And Alberta is presently at 11% but on its way to 8% which I personally think is too low. The carbon in the 2018-2019 budget year was projected to bring in $1.3 billion. Since the inception of the tax the NDP spent it all on rebates and on so-called green initiatives. And I happen to agree we need a sales tax. as for the oil by rail your forgetting the high up front cost and the revenue was projected not actually coming in yet. We wouldn't need oil by rail if pipelines could get built. And a $2.4 billion dollar handout?! Not really just asking to get back more of what we send to Ottawa. And Mustardman don't you live in Saskatchewan, you write as if your an Albertan!

[LWeber]

So let’s see if I have this straight. We had the lowest Corporate tax in the country, but we gave up $4.7 billion in taxes by reducing that by 33%. We scrapped the carbon tax which put $2 billion into revenue, now we pay federal carbon tax. We also cancelled rail contracts which would have put another $2 billion into revenue. And we refuse to impose a 5% sales tax which would add another $5 billion to our revenue. My question is this - “How much gall does it take the only Province in the Country without a sales tax, to go to Ottawa and claim to deserve a $2.4 billion handout?

When did you move to Alberta, Mustard.... You're throwing around "we" like you live there...

[woodland]

“We” need a Ralph Klein 2.0 like yesterday.

P.S. I can see the lights of Edmonton while I’m out shredding bales this morning.

[Horse]

“We” need a Ralph Klein 2.0 like yesterday.

P.S. I can see the lights of Edmonton while I’m out shredding bales this morning.

We allready have him( Kenny) Ralph was the worst permier alta ever had,before Alice in wonderland you seem to forget $14 gas ,blown up hosp no spending on infastructure,the only good thing ralph done was roll back wages.
Bought jets went fishing gambled and drank beer let all the mlas fill there pockets he was a cute Fu-ck-up.

[mustardman]

At 12% we didn't have the lowest corporate tax rate in Canada, Quebec is 11.6% and Ontario 11.5%. And Alberta is presently at 11% but on its way to 8% which I personally think is too low. The carbon in the 2018-2019 budget year was projected to bring in $1.3 billion. Since the inception of the tax the NDP spent it all on rebates and on so-called green initiatives. And I happen to agree we need a sales tax. as for the oil by rail your forgetting the high up front cost and the revenue was projected not actually coming in yet. We wouldn't need oil by rail if pipelines could get built. And a $2.4 billion dollar handout?! Not really just asking to get back more of what we send to Ottawa. And Mustardman don't you live in Saskatchewan, you write as if your an Albertan!

I Do live in Sask but as a Canadian Taxpayer, Alberta has some MAJOR Problems that will affect All taxpayers. Like the 100 Billion to clean up orphaned well which Alberta has ONLY collected $226 Million on!!! Bad management in the Petro State of Alberta will be paid by the public purse while the Oil Companies LAUGH all the way to the bank

[newguy]

Typical socialist believes everyone’s income belongs to the government. Why did mustardman forget to mention the real reason Alberta is unhappy?

Maybe the map should be broke down into smaller areas than provinces.parts of sask and Alberta has not been holding up their financial share of the pie also.

[Guest]

Maybe the map should be broke down into smaller areas than provinces.parts of sask and Alberta has not been holding up their financial share of the pie also.

that would be racist, my friend

[LEP]

I Do live in Sask but as a Canadian Taxpayer, Alberta has some MAJOR Problems that will affect All taxpayers. Like the 100 Billion to clean up orphaned well which Alberta has ONLY collected $226 Million on!!! Bad management in the Petro State of Alberta will be paid by the public purse while the Oil Companies LAUGH all the way to the bank

$100 Billion? Is that what you read in the commonwealth?

[Oliver88]

that would be racist, my friend

It would really point out the provincial NDP ridings. 🙀 These hammer and sickle ridings would have the highest unemployment and crime rates coincidentally I’m sure......

[mustardman]

$100 Billion? Is that what you read in the commonwealth?

Alberta Energy Regulator -Robert Wadsworth estimates 100 billion to clean up oil wells and another 30 billion for pipelines-
his figures Not mine