High speed discs

[bgmb]

How long till the protills and jokers are all parked in the fenceline


https://www.manitobacooperator.ca/crops/soil-erosion-lessons-learned-and-forgotten/?module=carousel&pgtype=homepage&i=1

[blackpowder]

As soon as the dry comes back.

[seldomseen]

If it stays dry there will be big dollar items that won't get used. Most of them were bought to fill ruts around here.

[Braveheart]

Keep using high speed disks and you'll be parking them in a fenceline full of drift soil.

[Partners]

Even here in the Wet belt..Neighbors quit using them..

[farmaholic]

Because of the high speed required to operate them and frequent turning, are they even practical to use them only for low spots?

Our land doesn't require "blanket" tillage to manage crop residue....too variable. Heavy harrows on a hot day is good enough in most cases.....ya, we had the odd year where there was a bit too much straw, but if we can get the drill through it we live with the results

Even turned down repeated requests from cattlepeoples(sorry, I couldn't help myself) to bale straw off our land.....sorry, it isn't going to happen. Too much abuse from decades of cultivation that I will never see restored to presettlement conditions in my lifetime....or maybe not for three generations.

I even hate burning the flax straw....our combine, MAV chopper, drill combination doesn't work for seeding through it.

[hobbyfrmr]

I could use another one....possibly 2 if they are small and cheap enough. We dont fill ruts, its full on intrusive tillage and hyper consumption of fossil fuels. Tractor hours and rapid depreciation.
Sometimes...twice on Sunday.

[saskshafe]

Had the same thoughts as you guys on them. Finally got a good used one this fall. We heavy harrowed some canola stubble this fall, as well as disked some across the road to level the rust out. The disk left some lumps on top. Had a couple of those 100km/hr winds this fall, and the harrowed stuff drifted like a bugger while the disked stuff stayed put. I hope that it rots in the bush after we get our ruts and sloughs looked after, which will take a few years, but I was quite surprised on the drifting side of it.
This is high assessed land, not light sand.

[farmaholic]

Had the same thoughts as you guys on them. Finally got a good used one this fall. We heavy harrowed some canola stubble this fall, as well as disked some across the road to level the rust out. The disk left some lumps on top. Had a couple of those 100km/hr winds this fall, and the harrowed stuff drifted like a bugger while the disked stuff stayed put. I hope that it rots in the bush after we get our ruts and sloughs looked after, which will take a few years, but I was quite surprised on the drifting side of it.
This is high assessed land, not light sand.

Which make did you buy?

[biglentil]

Had the same thoughts as you guys on them. Finally got a good used one this fall. We heavy harrowed some canola stubble this fall, as well as disked some across the road to level the rust out. The disk left some lumps on top. Had a couple of those 100km/hr winds this fall, and the harrowed stuff drifted like a bugger while the disked stuff stayed put. I hope that it rots in the bush after we get our ruts and sloughs looked after, which will take a few years, but I was quite surprised on the drifting side of it.
This is high assessed land, not light sand.

Yep saw the same thing