StatsCan... Agriweek comment...

[farmaholic]

Derail;

Ergo the land prices in some.of those "areas".

Re: StatsCan, they quit calling when I refused to responde, even after the threats, for rhe umpteenth time. And I was never disrespectful or impolite.

Why is it so important that everyone one know these numbers? What's wrong with a little secrecy when it comes to production and avaiable stocks?

[bucket]

Until all other in the supply chain report, I see no reason to report either.

They want to blame farmers - **** off - find a new methodology to determine what's out there.

Or make it mandatory for all industry players to report.

[Guest]

my sentiments exactly !

[LEP]

I know a neighbour with a 1000 to nes in the bins. He built more bins for this years crop.

[bucket]

Now if you can 500 to 1000 more like him you can find the statscan errors.

[SASKFARMER3]

Last year and most I had around 30000 to 60000 carry over but a 12.00 was good enough for me so bins were empty of canola as most in the east.
Stats can is full of shit.
Use crop insurance more people responding and its exact or measured.

[farmaholic]

SF3, but why do "they" need to know? Answer that with a realistic answer. Not a "so we can help you better" response. Not that you would reply that way anyway but why do they need to know? Why is it so important....

Charlie Pearson?

[bucket]

I thought the market knew everything. ?

[furrowtickler]

Like it or not , Statscan reports move markets one way or the other - traders need that info, false or otherwise to make money - Its all about the dog and pony show for everyone else in the ag industry to extract every last penny from the primary producers pockets.. before any single fact is really on the plate . Buy the rumor - sell the fact.
With the sat info available some of the industry knows day to day what yields are going to be barring frost/hail events long before the Sarcan reports come out.

[farming101]

There is no reason to blame farmers for the seeming problem with inaccurate on farm canola stocks.
The statscan survey is only an estimate and will need to be corrected when the numbers don't add up. I doubt any serious grain speculator trades based on statscan.
Look at the price action the last few days. Did it really change all that much after the news came out?
Yearend stocks in the system were more than adequate, 1,300,000 tonnes in store or in transit. Basis reflected that fact. No way there was a shortage of canola and the trade knew it. Basis widened, price weakened, and that's all the news we needed to hear.