Organic works

[sumdumguy]

I know some people who farmed organically under OCIA. Please note past tense. They said the rules were too stringent. They sold the farm, mostly due to health reasons.

[parsley]

Making money is a cardinal sin, Aggie. Pray for me. Hard. Pars.

[agstar77]

There is only one reason to go organic. Only if you can make more money.

[LEP]

I am going piss some people off here.

I was talking to a very senior individual with a grain co. And he commented that somethings make him uncomfortable with organic. He has an organic facility and stated that all product is delivered under affidavit. Meaning it isn't tested for pesticide residue.

There are several customers that are partially organic and part conventional. But miraculously the organic land far out yields conventional.

Sounds like a pretty big loophole to me.

[hobbyfrmr]

This thread is crazy you anti chemical and conventional fertilizer guys are like a religious cult. Totally irrational

I just posted above that its not worth the risk.

[fjlip]

Still laughing and feel sorry for the organic farmers, the WEED infested fields, with enough seeds for many years, they stay viable. There is NO solution after they fall into the soil, land is screwed. Tillage is a joke. Grass for years may work if you want that business.

[AllisWD45]

Quite the discussion. In 1988 i direct seeded for the first time. The whole neighbourhood was in an uproar. The fool has really gone off the deep end. He will be broke in 2 years. It will never work. the fields are so rough. WEEDS will take over he is not cultivating. The land will turn to cement.It looks like shit. By the year 2000 the neighbours were all doing it and they didn't go broke either. We have now come full circle and the accepted norm is direct seeding and all that goes with it. It didn't take long. what will be the norm in another 30 years?
I leave you with A thought from Gandhi.
First they ignore you
Second they laugh at you
Third they fight you.
Fourth you win

[bgmb]

This thread is crazy you anti chemical and conventional fertilizer guys are like a religious cult. Totally irrational

[bgmb]

Klause nitrogen is nitrogen, there is no such thing as synthetic nitrogen. Go take a chemistry course or talk to a real unbiased soil scientist. They will tell you nh3 is as good as any other n source.

Micros are a waste of time 95 percent of the time. The universities have done trials and research it doesn't pay.

So you aren't really organic just but don't use nitrogen or sprays I really can't graso how the economics of that can work with no premium for the grain.

[grassfarmer]

Patures have been badly abused in these parts. Obviously rain would help immensely but even with it I still think they are poorly managed, over the long-term. Seems some people can't get their head around excess grass.

Don Campbell the SK HM educator and rancher says "once you've grown grass it's impossible to waste it". Once you understand that you can make all kinds of progress.