How does it start?

[burnt]

Jensend - you ask a profound question in this - "...where does sharing start and stop and how much of the risk of what we decide to do for a living are we to carry on our own..."

I wonder what those who opened this great land up would think if they were here to see the relatively coddled "lifestyle" that is farming today.

Who knew/knows real risk?

[Burbert]

Sell the crap on the open market, that
already exists, er donchaknowthat, you
markeetearing genioussssss!!!!!
Confiscate, what? Bags of wind, don'tcha
get paid when ya sells something. Seems
that you don't know what confiscated
means, nor really! Do ya?

[Fransisco]

For the record, I'm generally not in favour of these "subsidy" type payments.

But jensend I think you're forgetting something. Farmers pay tax's too.

When a farmer gets a check from the government, agristability, agri-invest, whatever, is he really getting someone else's money? Or is he maybe getting back some of what got taken from him in the first place.

Eliminate the tax burden on farmers and you have a point. But as long as we're getting taxed through the nose on everything its not quite so cut and dried.

[Fransisco]

wilagro your comment shows us in spades what the problem is. You don't even recognize that somebody else's property, is somebody else's property. There are far too many people in power with exactly that kind of attitude.

[silverback]

That is what keeps sticking out to me Fran.

If you held these cwb lovers down and threatened to pull out their fingernails with vice grips unless they admitted that every farmer owns the grain produced on their own farm, I don't think they could admit it. I have never heard any of them, going all the way back to Vader that would say it. Is it just wheat? Malt barley? How is it that they want to share everyone else's wheat crop but not their own canola, lentil, peas, etc...? Where and when does the envy or the feeling of entitlement to someone else's production start?

Boggling...

[Fransisco]

How far back do you want to go? I've heard people argue that it goes back to the german philosopher Immanuel Kant. Others have argued that it goes back to Plato.

Unfortunately this attitude has been with us a long, long time.

[AdamSmith]

Great question!

My theory is it starts when someone is young and has a mind full of mush, when mommy and daddy are making all decisions for them. Life consists of nothing but you can do this but not that, and not that and definitely not that. Unfortunately the desire to shelter your kids from the real world when they are young creates young socialist. Those who have trouble being adults later in life remain socialists, those who yearn to chart their own path and yearn for the responsibility of adulthood grow up to be capitalists.

I kid my parents about abandoning me as a youth. They didn’t really abandon me they just enjoyed living their own lives and all too often I was left for a weekend with my sister to look after me. But as soon as the car or the motorhome turned the corner a mile down the road, my sister would jump in her car and be gone. I loved it and never let on my sister would be gone the whole time they were. There was no one around to tell me I couldn’t do all the stupid things I wanted to do, like drive my dirtbike 15 miles to town and hang out with my buddies or take dad’s 4x4 out and pretend I was racing the BAJA 1000. (I was 14 at the time). Cool stuff but along the way I was learning responsibility. I couldn’t escape the realities of dealing with the police confiscating the dirtbike when we got caught ripping through town at midnight or I had to accept my fate when dad sees grass jammed between every tire and wheel on his F-150 4x4. I was learning early in life freedom meant the joy in doing what YOU choose to do, but also accepting responsibility when I chose poorly. I was learning what it was like to be an adult. So when I kid them about abandoning me also thank them for it because it gave me a great head start on learning how to be an adult.