Chas & tom4cwb, interesting debate. Chas, like it or not we've always had speculators in the food chain. Look back (away back) to the time before the CBOT when grain dealers in Chicago bought grain in the countryside with the idea that they would move it to the mills in Chicago and make more profit than a small return on investment over and above their costs of transporting it to Chicago. In that environment farmers and local warehousemen were at the mercies of these Chicago grain dealers who thoroughly understood the wheat market but didn't share that info with producers and warehousemen. They were the speculators in their time and they were very few in number.
More recently we have different (or other) speculators in the marketplace. We have farmers who hold their product waiting for the price to go higher. We have farm product buyers who buy product in advance of sales hoping to earn more than a margin over and above their costs of getting product to buyers (which every once in a while culls out a significant number of companies because the market goes down after they've bought product). We have international merchants of let's say, chickpeas, who buy Canadian product and hope the price in their destination country hasn't gone down before they get the chickpeas into the consuming market. We have countries like China exporting corn at opportune times hoping to buy it back later at a lower price. Right now we have feedlots buying feeder cattle at prices well above breakeven specing that slaughter cattle prices will have risen by the time these cattle are ready for slaughter.
For some time now, we have had very large speculators (funds) specing in futures. There's no doubt they create increased volatility in the futures market. That volatility drives prices higher at times and lower at other times than they should be (in the short run) based on straight supply-demand numbers. However, it's very important to remember that volatility creates opportunities for those willing to take advantage of them. Tom4cwb is right about canola, for example. Funds specing on a rise in canola have bought new-crop canola futures and their very strong buying has driven the prices an extimated $20 to $30 a tonne above where supply-demand numbers dictate they "should" be. Of course, crushers have been in there buying, too, as a hedge for incoming supplies in case there really is a very short crop in Canada. Again, though, right now is a tremendous selling or hedging opportunity for growers of new-crop canola, mostly created by funds going long (buying) November canola futures and driving the price up.
Marketing on the farm is all about taking advantage of opportunities. My experience is that is what separates successful marketers from those who either don't know about the opportunities or are too cautious to take advantage of them.
Lee
More recently we have different (or other) speculators in the marketplace. We have farmers who hold their product waiting for the price to go higher. We have farm product buyers who buy product in advance of sales hoping to earn more than a margin over and above their costs of getting product to buyers (which every once in a while culls out a significant number of companies because the market goes down after they've bought product). We have international merchants of let's say, chickpeas, who buy Canadian product and hope the price in their destination country hasn't gone down before they get the chickpeas into the consuming market. We have countries like China exporting corn at opportune times hoping to buy it back later at a lower price. Right now we have feedlots buying feeder cattle at prices well above breakeven specing that slaughter cattle prices will have risen by the time these cattle are ready for slaughter.
For some time now, we have had very large speculators (funds) specing in futures. There's no doubt they create increased volatility in the futures market. That volatility drives prices higher at times and lower at other times than they should be (in the short run) based on straight supply-demand numbers. However, it's very important to remember that volatility creates opportunities for those willing to take advantage of them. Tom4cwb is right about canola, for example. Funds specing on a rise in canola have bought new-crop canola futures and their very strong buying has driven the prices an extimated $20 to $30 a tonne above where supply-demand numbers dictate they "should" be. Of course, crushers have been in there buying, too, as a hedge for incoming supplies in case there really is a very short crop in Canada. Again, though, right now is a tremendous selling or hedging opportunity for growers of new-crop canola, mostly created by funds going long (buying) November canola futures and driving the price up.
Marketing on the farm is all about taking advantage of opportunities. My experience is that is what separates successful marketers from those who either don't know about the opportunities or are too cautious to take advantage of them.
Lee
Comment